Post
by John Link » Sun Jan 27, 2019 8:45 pm
Be careful with the zero fret and hammering, if you hammer it in. (Don't know your plans.) Hammering it in puts enough lateral pressure on the wood above it so as to cause that little chunk to either split or actually part company with the fret board, according to reports I have read. Myself, I've never used one but intend to, as I think the ZF is probably the "better mouse trap" compared to the traditional nut. My thinking is like yours, that it ought to be a little higher than the other frets to provide for vigorous plucking of open strings when the music benefits from that. But there is more to it than this. Zero frets, if NOT driven in, provide an easy way to adjust action. That is ...
Leave the slot wide enough for the zero fret so that it can easily be interchanged with frets of higher or lower vertical clearance, to suit the owner and his or her playing style. Unlike all the other frets, the zero fret is kept in its slot simply from the downward force of the strings. Might want to reinforce the slot with generous amounts of CA glue and use a fret with a long vertical. And perhaps file down the "grippers" to facilitate getting it in and out without damaging the sides of the slot.
If one wanted to get really tight about it all, the treble end of the "taller" ZF could be filed down so that it did not provide as much space between the unwound B and E strings and the first fret, thereby making them a little easier to punch down. The bare strings are harder to fret compared to the wound, for me at least. In any case, zero frets can be adjusted, just like nuts, if you start out with one that is tall enough. There is no law that says it must be the same height all the way across.
As part of the whole package of a custom built guitar, you could provide several zero frets each with a different height, assuming removal would not entail damage to its slot. You can do this with nuts too, but it is a lot more work. And nut removal is somewhat destructive.
Food for thought, anyway.
John